Store Nostalgic Store/Candy/NostalgicSort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AFiltersClear allFiltersClear allShow itemsShow itemsCherry CocktailCherry Cocktail$2.49 Buy NowStrawberry Shortcake ChewsStrawberry Shortcake Chews$0.20 Buy NowMoon Pies - Salted CaramelMoon Pies - Salted Caramel$1.89 Buy NowMoon Pie - VanillaMoon Pie - Vanilla$1.89 Buy NowReeds ButterscotchReeds Butterscotch$2.09 Buy NowBubble Gum CigarettesBubble Gum Cigarettes$1.99 Buy NowGoodart's Peanut PattieGoodart's Peanut Pattie$2.29 Buy NowBit-o-honey bagBit-o-honey bag$3.19 Buy NowReeds Root BeerReeds Root Beer$2.09 Buy NowMoon Pie - BananaMoon Pie - Banana$1.89 Buy Nowlifesavers butter rumlifesavers butter rum$2.09 Buy NowClaeys - Old Fashioned PeppermintClaeys - Old Fashioned Peppermint$3.19 Buy NowStick Candy - CherryStick Candy - Cherry$0.50 Buy NowZotz Cherry Apple WatermelonZotz Cherry Apple Watermelon$0.99 Buy NowRazzlesRazzles$2.89 Buy NowStick Candy - RaspberryStick Candy - Raspberry$0.50 Buy NowStick Candy - tutti fruttiStick Candy - tutti frutti$0.50 Buy NowMoon Pie- ChocolateMoon Pie- Chocolate$1.89 Buy NowStick Candy - Grape - DStick Candy - Grape - D$0.50 Buy NowMcGraws Giant Taffy McGraws Giant Taffy $1.99 Buy Nowreeds peppermint Dreeds peppermint D$2.09 Buy NowZotzs - Blue Raspberry Orange GrapeZotzs - Blue Raspberry Orange Grape$0.99 Buy NowCaramel Apple PopCaramel Apple Pop$0.89 Buy Nowcanela's gumcanela's gum$0.20 Buy NowStick Candy - ButterscotchStick Candy - Butterscotch$0.50 Buy NowStick Candy - Cotton CandyStick Candy - Cotton Candy$0.50 Buy NowCherry MashCherry Mash$2.99 Buy NowBeemans GumBeemans Gum$0.99 Buy NowStick Candy - Birthday CakeStick Candy - Birthday Cake$0.50 Buy NowBlack Jack GumBlack Jack Gum$0.99 Buy NowSugar Daddy PopSugar Daddy Pop$2.99 Buy NowNik-l-Nip 8pkNik-l-Nip 8pk$3.49 Buy NowBig HunkBig Hunk$2.89 Buy NowCandy CigarettesCandy Cigarettes$1.99 Buy NowStick Candy - CinnamonStick Candy - Cinnamon$0.50 Buy NowStick Candy - BlueberryStick Candy - Blueberry$0.50 Buy NowStick Candy - Root BeerStick Candy - Root Beer$0.50 Buy NowReeds PeppermintReeds Peppermint$1.76 Buy NowBazooka gumBazooka gum$0.25 Buy NowChick o StickChick o Stick$2.79 Buy NowNecco WaferNecco Wafer$2.29 Buy NowRegal Crown Lemon DRegal Crown Lemon D$0.50 Buy NowBanana Split ChewsBanana Split Chews$0.20 Buy Nowteaberry gumteaberry gum$0.99 Buy NowMary Jane-Molasses & Peanut ButterMary Jane-Molasses & Peanut Butter$3.29 Buy NowNecco Chocolate WafersNecco Chocolate Wafers$2.29 Buy NowAlbert's 5ct Ice CubeAlbert's 5ct Ice Cube$3.99 Buy NowCharleston ChewCharleston Chew$2.39 Buy NowClaeys Old Fashioned Lemon DropClaeys Old Fashioned Lemon Drop$3.19 Buy NowNik l Nip SourNik l Nip Sour$3.49 Buy NowStick Candy - BananaStick Candy - Banana$0.50 Buy NowRegal Crown Sour Cherry DRegal Crown Sour Cherry D$0.50 Buy NowClaey's Old Fashioned horehoundClaey's Old Fashioned horehound$3.19 Buy NowChucklesChuckles$2.89 Buy NowStick Candy - ChocomintStick Candy - Chocomint$0.50 Buy NowStick Candy - SmoresStick Candy - Smores$0.50 Buy NowBubblegum CigarsBubblegum Cigars$1.29 Buy NowStick Candy - OrangeStick Candy - Orange$0.50 Buy NowStick Candy - LemonStick Candy - Lemon$0.50 Buy NowStick Candy - PeppermintStick Candy - Peppermint$0.50 Buy Now1 - 60 of 72 itemsPrev12Next
